Siding Brick or Stucco? Orlando’s Guide to Exterior Wall Replacement
Does your home’s exterior look worn, cracked, or outdated? You’re not alone—many Orlando homeowners start thinking about how to replace stucco when they notice hairline cracks, mold growth, or rising energy bills. The Florida climate can be harsh on stucco exteriors, especially if not properly installed or maintained.
If you're debating between siding, brick, or stucco for your next exterior wall replacement, this guide breaks it all down. From building permits to the best materials for curb appeal and durability, here’s what every homeowner in Orlando should know.
What’s the Best Material for Your Orlando Home Exterior?
Whether you're renovating your home near Lake Eola or building new construction in Winter Park, the right exterior wall material affects more than just looks. It impacts your home’s energy efficiency, fire resistance, and resale value.
| Material | Pros | Cons | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stucco Siding | - Fire resistant and energy-efficient - Durable when properly installed - Customizable with different textures and finishes | - Easily damaged by water if not sealed - Needs regular maintenance and inspections - Hard to repair exact texture | Common in Florida. Replace stucco when cracks and mold appear. Always hire a licensed stucco contractor familiar with Orlando's permitting and climate. |
| Brick Siding | - Long-lasting and low maintenance - Fire and weather resistant - Boosts property value | - Higher upfront cost - May require extra structural support | Ideal for homes in wind-prone areas. Complements stone or wood features. |
| Vinyl Siding | - Budget-friendly - Rot and insect resistant - Easy to install and maintain | - Less durable in extreme heat - Prone to impact damage - Color may fade | Best when paired with good insulation and shade. Popular for affordability in Orlando neighborhoods. |
| Wood & Fiber Cement | Fiber Cement Pros: - Fire and rot resistant - Durable wood-like appearance - Low maintenance | Fiber Cement Cons: - Heavier than other sidings - Needs professional installation | Wood is beautiful but high maintenance. Fiber cement offers the look of wood with better performance—ideal for long-term investment in Orlando homes. |
Do You Need a Permit to Replace Stucco or Siding in Orlando?
Yes. In Orlando, replacing stucco or any exterior wall material typically requires a building permit. This includes major siding repairs, installing brick veneer, or modifying garage doors and windows during the process.
Here’s what to know:
- Required permit: Any structural changes or material replacements
- Electrical permit: Needed if wiring is affected during wall repair
- Fence permits: If replacing walls near accessory structures or fences
- Final inspection: Always conducted to ensure compliance
Visit the City of Orlando Permitting Portal for up-to-date forms and zoning details.
When Should You Replace Stucco on Your Orlando Home?
Not all cracks mean it’s time to tear everything down. But some signs signal it’s time to replace stucco instead of doing another patch job.
Key Signs You Need Stucco Replacement
- Large or spreading cracks: Hairline cracks are normal, but wider cracks could indicate underlying issues like water damage or foundation movement.
- Soft or bubbling areas: These are often caused by trapped moisture behind the walls.
- Visible mold growth or rot: Especially around windows or near garage doors, mold means water has breached the stucco layer.
- Recurring repair needs: If you’ve already done stucco repair more than once and new issues keep popping up, a full replacement might be cheaper in the long run.
- Paint won't hold: If fresh stucco can’t hold paint properly, the existing stucco layer may be too damaged.
Stucco removal and replacement is often necessary when water intrusion, plumbing leaks, or old stucco installation methods cause structural issues.
What to Expect When You Replace Stucco
Replacing stucco isn’t just cosmetic—it’s a construction process. Here’s a simplified overview of what to expect:
Assessment
A qualified contractor inspects for stucco damage, hidden cracks, and underlying issues like bad flashing or poor sealing.
Stucco Removal
The crew strips off the old stucco, typically using saws or pneumatic tools. This exposes the concrete or wood underneath.
Moisture Barrier & Prep
New waterproof barriers, mesh, or sheathing are added to prevent future water damage or mold buildup.
Stucco Installation or Siding Replacement
If you're sticking with fresh stucco, new layers of sand, cement, and finish coats are applied. If switching to something like vinyl or James Hardie siding, installers follow manufacturer specs for proper mounting and sealing.
Finishing Touches
Painting (if required), new windows or garage doors, and final inspection to ensure the job meets local codes.
Tips for Orlando Homeowners: Choosing the Right Material
When planning an exterior update in Central Florida, consider:
- Climate: Stucco performs well in warm weather but needs regular maintenance.
- Style: Choose materials that match your home's architecture and surrounding neighborhood.
- Curb Appeal: If selling soon, materials like fiber cement or brick can increase value.
- Maintenance: Vinyl and fiber cement are low maintenance. Wood requires frequent sealing and painting.
- Cost: Budget not just for materials but also for permits, inspections, and long-term upkeep.
Also, don’t forget drainage—ensure garden hoses and nearby soil don’t cause water to collect near your home’s base.
Upgrade Your Walls with Confidence
If you’re starting to notice cracks, water damage, or fading surfaces, it may be time to replace stucco or consider a new siding material. Orlando homeowners have great options—whether you're drawn to the modern appeal of fiber cement, the classic strength of brick, or the affordability of vinyl siding.
Need expert help deciding what's best for your home? Contact Orlando Stucco Repair Pros for a professional inspection and quote today.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know when it’s time to replace stucco on my home?
If you see hairline cracks, bubbling paint, mold spots, or feel increased humidity inside your home, it may be time to replace stucco. A professional inspection can confirm if repairs are enough or if a full replacement is needed.
Do I need a building permit to replace exterior siding in Orlando?
Yes. Orlando requires a building permit for replacing stucco, vinyl, brick, or any exterior wall surface. You may also need an electrical permit if wiring is involved. Always check with the city’s permitting department before starting.
What is the most low maintenance siding option?
Vinyl siding and fiber cement are the top choices for low maintenance. Both resist rot, pests, and fading, making them ideal for Orlando’s hot and humid climate.
Is stucco or brick better for fire resistance?
Both materials are highly fire resistant. However, stucco has the added benefit of energy efficiency, while brick offers exceptional durability and a more traditional look.
Can I replace stucco with another material like vinyl or fiber cement?
Yes. You can replace stucco with vinyl, fiber cement, or brick, depending on your budget and style goals. Just make sure the new material is properly installed and all permitting requirements are followed.
RECENT BLOGS
